IT Disaster Recovery Testing Best Practices

A challenge many organizations face is understanding if and how they would recover from a disaster or malware event that takes down their information technology (IT) infrastructure or data center. Nearly every organization relies heavily on IT and may be unable to conduct business without it. Drawing from my experience managing the IT infrastructure at a midsized community bank, these best practices provide actionable steps to help you prepare and test for unforeseen disasters to keep your business operational.

Understanding IT Disaster Recovery Testing

IT disaster recovery (DR) testing is a critical component of any organization’s disaster recovery strategy. It validates your ability to restore IT systems and business operations after disruptions such as system failures, cyberattacks, or natural disasters. The primary objectives are to identify gaps in your recovery plans, ensure your systems are prepared to resume operations quickly, and confirm that recovery time objectives (RTOs) and recovery point objectives (RPOs) specified in the business impact analysis (BIA) are achievable. DR testing also verifies your organization’s capacity to recover and restore essential data and processes while aligning with operational priorities.

Regular DR testing is essential for maintaining recovery readiness. By defining the scope of testing, prioritizing critical systems, and simulating realistic disaster scenarios, organizations can uncover weaknesses, fine-tune their strategies, and foster collaboration between IT teams and business leaders. This iterative process minimizes downtime and builds confidence in the organization’s ability to respond effectively to unforeseen disruptions.

To maintain readiness, IT DR testing should be performed at least annually. Larger organizations may require more frequent testing to address evolving risks and ensure their recovery strategies remain up to date and effective.

Disaster Recovery Testing Phases

The IT DR testing process involves several phases, which may vary based on your DR infrastructure’s structure:

1. DR plan review: Verify the disaster recovery plan’s accuracy and ensure all participants understand their roles. If using a managed service provider (MSP), involve them in this phase.
2. DR walk-through: Conduct a structured walk-through with key personnel to identify gaps or missing steps in the plan.
3. DR tabletop exercise: Bring the IT DR team together to discuss responsibilities, refine processes, and validate checklists for testing critical applications and data.
4. Mock testing: Perform small-scale tests on specific components, such as verifying virtual server replication, to confirm recovery processes without disrupting production systems.
5. Parallel test: Test the DR environment alongside the production environment, ensuring recovery processes work without handling live transactions or causing production downtime.
6. Full failover test: Execute a complete failover to the DR site, run operations, and fail back to the original environment to validate full disaster readiness.

Best Practices for Disaster Recovery Testing

Effective disaster recovery testing is critical to ensuring an organization can recover swiftly and efficiently from any disruption. These best practices outline essential strategies to enhance your IT disaster recovery planning, safeguard critical data, and maintain business continuity in a wide range of scenarios.

Define Your Recovery Objectives

The first step in refining your disaster recovery testing plan is to assess how dependent your organization is on its IT systems. If all IT resources are down, servicing customers may become impossible, making it essential to establish goals, requirements, and priorities for recovering those resources. Engagement from management is crucial in these decisions. A quality BIA should already be in place to guide decisions and set priorities for recovering your most critical business processes. When developing or refining your plan, consider the following recovery factors:

• Impacts: Assess the potential customer, financial, legal, and resource impacts of IT disruptions.
• Time frames: Define your RPO, RTO, and maximum tolerable downtime (MTD).

Strategize Your Disaster Recovery Testing

Several critical decisions must be made to ensure your IT DR plan effectively aligns with your recovery objectives. First, evaluate whether your organization possesses a dedicated DR site, relies on an MSP, or has robust backup and recovery capabilities in place. It's essential to confirm the reliability of your data backups and the capability of your infrastructure to meet these stringent requirements.

Organizations can choose from various IT DR strategies depending on their downtime tolerance and budget:

On-Site Manual Restore

Backing up all your data locally and restoring it on-site manually requires very little upfront cost, but it takes a long time to procure and build the infrastructure. Additionally, on-site manual restoration is very difficult to test. It may take weeks to recover using an on-site manual restore method.

Cold Site

A cold site is an alternate location with some equipment available but not running or configured. Recovery at a cold site requires a full infrastructure build-out, data recovery, and system restoration. This process can be time-intensive, resulting in a longer recovery timeline than other DR options.

Warm Site

A warm site has operational infrastructure and connectivity and is ready to receive restored data. Organizations with multiple locations often designate one of their alternate sites as a DR facility, outfitted with redundant equipment to support recovery efforts. While effective, the warm site method requires maintaining infrastructure and software, which adds to operational costs.

Hot Site

A hot site is ideal for organizations with minimal tolerance for downtime. It features a redundant infrastructure that mirrors the production environment, with constant data replication to ensure seamless failover. In the event of a disaster, a hot site can handle the full production load with only a brief interruption in operations, making it the fastest and most reliable option for recovery.

Disaster Recovery as a Service (DRaaS)

DRaaS is a new concept in IT DR planning. Organizations that don’t want to maintain a DR site can partner with a DRaaS provider, offering cloud-based infrastructure as the target for data replication and recovery of critical data and business applications. This can be a great solution for organizations of any size that want to maintain high uptime guarantees without the burden of maintaining their own DR site.

MSP-Provided DR

Organizations with infrastructure hosted by an MSP (infrastructure as a service, or IaaS) can rely on their provider to maintain a DR site. It’s very important to have a documented agreement with the MSP stating how the recovery process will be structured with a service-level agreement (SLA) detailing the priorities and requirements. SLAs should define the frequency and type of testing performed and any penalties if the objectives are not met.

Back Up All Data and Replication Essentials

Another key component of IT DR is establishing a solid data backup and replication strategy. Your BIA helps determine whether data replication is needed for your IT DR site to meet RTO requirements. A long-standing best practice in data protection is the 3-2-1 backup rule: Maintain at least three copies of your data on two different media types, with one copy stored off-site. However, as cyber threats like ransomware evolve, organizations may benefit from adapting to a 3-2-2 strategy: Maintain two off-site copies, one in an alternate location and another in an immutable cloud backup archive.

Regular testing is critical to verify that backup data can be restored and remains intact. Monthly backup validation ensures that recovery procedures work as expected and that backups haven’t been compromised.

The recommended backup retention schedule varies by organization, but as a general guideline:

• Minimum: Retain backups for at least 14 days.
• Best practice: Maintain a 30-day retention schedule, supplemented with quarterly and yearly archives for long-term recovery needs.

Communication

Effective communication is essential throughout all phases of IT DR testing. Management should be fully informed about the test planning, execution, and outcomes. Early scheduling helps ensure stakeholder availability and minimizes disruptions. Remember to include critical third parties in the testing process and consider using audits, screenshots, or logs to validate the test results.

Execute Your Disaster Recovery Test

At least a week before testing, verify that the IT DR systems are fully operational and accurately reflect the current production environment.

Essential items for testing include:

• IT DR plan
• Testing checklist
• Comprehensive contact list (including vendors)
• Detailed network diagrams
• Internet access for research

Before testing begins, all participants should understand their roles and responsibilities. To maintain an orderly process, designate a lead coordinator (typically a manager) to guide the team through each phase.

During the test:

• Follow the IT DR plan as your primary runbook. Note any missing or inaccurate details for post-test review.
• Assign an official notetaker to document activities and timestamps to confirm whether RTOs are being met.
• Keep the team updated on recovery progress and any issues encountered. Reallocate resources if needed to minimize delays.

After the test, revert all systems to production status and verify normal operations. Notify management of the test results and highlight any areas for improvement.

Reporting: Lessons Learned

Following an IT DR test, the team must conduct a formal review to document findings and refine the process. Key discussion points include:

• Effectiveness: Were RTOs achieved? Did the IT DR plan provide clear and actionable guidance?
• Challenges: What obstacles were encountered, and how can they be addressed in a real disaster?
• Improvements: What changes should be made to enhance resilience?

The testing results and lessons learned should be formally documented and provided to management and the board of directors. The report should cover:

• Test scope and objectives
• Resources used during testing
• Performance evaluation of IT DR systems
• Identified gaps and necessary updates
• Scheduling for any follow-up testing

Common Pitfalls in IT Disaster Recovery Testing and How to Avoid Them

Even with a well-documented IT DR plan, organizations often face challenges during testing. Common pitfalls include:

• Unclear scope: Testing is too limited or too broad, leading to ineffective assessments.
• Lack of stakeholder involvement: Key teams or external vendors are not engaged in the process.
• Insufficient documentation: Test results are not properly recorded, making future improvements difficult.

To avoid these pitfalls:

• Clearly define test objectives and include all critical systems.
• Involve IT, business leaders, and third-party service providers.
• Maintain thorough documentation to track progress and refine the IT DR plan over time.

The Role of Technology in Maturing IT Disaster Recovery Testing

Advancements in technology are transforming IT DR testing, making recovery faster and more reliable. Innovations include:

• Cloud-based DR: Enables rapid data replication across multiple locations for faster recovery.
• Automation tools: Streamline repetitive tasks, such as system restores, reducing human error.
• AI-driven insights: Predict potential failures, optimize testing schedules, and improve response strategies.

By integrating these technologies, organizations can enhance IT DR effectiveness, reduce downtime, and improve overall resilience.

Your Next Steps to a Stronger IT Disaster Recovery Plan

IT DR testing ensures your organization can recover IT operations quickly and effectively following a disaster. Research consistently shows that downtime and data loss can lead to severe financial and reputational damage. For example, according to IBM, the global average cost of a data breach in 2024 reached $4.88 million — a 10% increase over 2023. This underscores the need for robust IT DR testing to mitigate potential losses.

Building a mature IT DR program requires ongoing commitment and continuous improvement. By regularly testing and refining your IT DR strategy, your organization can minimize downtime and operational disruptions and protect critical data and IT infrastructure.

How Can SBS Help?

Build Resilience with Confidence

Read More

Incident Readiness Assessment

Run a comprehensive assessment of your incident preparedness and get specific recommendations to enhance your readiness for the future.

Read More

Read More

Virtual CISO

Utilize our knowledge and experience, combined with your team's insights into internal processes, to create a tailored approach to cybersecurity.

Read More